Suggested by iKnowledge Venat is a very skilled healer and someone who excels at being a support class fighter. She certainly wouldn’t be going down easily but Makarov is much more adept at offensive spells. He should be able to easily keep her at bay with hi attacks and healing can only take you so far. She doesn’t have the speed to keep up with him, nor the durability to stay in the ring after a few hits. This is why she will end up going down. Makarov Dreyar wins.
DReager1.com
The Ultimate Fighting/Review Site
DReager1.com 
Are you counting when Venat fused with Vayne in Final Fantasy XII? Because that should give Venat more than a chance. I don’t doubt Makarov’s power in his universe, but just asking?
Yeah the fusion definitely makes things closer but I still don’t see Venat being able to match Makarov’s raw power. That guy was an absolute beast before old age ended up defeating him