I’ve been eating at Crumbl Cookies for a long time. You might even say that I am a bit of a veteran among the cookie departments. I’ve been eating cookies longer than most people have been eating Turduckens and I’m going to keep on eating them for many years to come. I’ve been meaning to do a rankings type post for a long while but figured I’d let the flavors build up some more. They never really end though as every week something new is out so I figured 166 flavors was a good time to jump in. I’m not going to give images or descriptions for all of them as that would be crazy but I’ll do general break throughs and certainly images for some of the heavy hitters.

Credit to https://crumblcookieflavors.com/ for easily allowing me to keep track of the cookies I eat and for the easy formatting.

Now lets dive into this! What is the ultimate flavor out of Crumbl Cookie’s impressive arsenal?

1 🔵 BLUE MONSTER FT. CHIPS AHOY!®
2 🤎 GRAHAM CRACKER FUDGE SANDWICH
3 COOKIE DOUGH
4 🥛 MALLOW SANDWICH FT. OREO®
5 CANNOLI
6 DOUBLE FUDGE BROWNIE
7 COOKIES & CREAM MILKSHAKE
8 TRIPLE CHOCOLATE CHIP
9 DOUBLE CHOCOLATE CHIP
10 🍫 DOUBLE FUDGE BROWNIE (LTO)

You can’t beat a cookie on top of another cookie. This was a brilliant idea and I don’t think it will ever be surpassed. I ate so many of these when it came out and I would definitely double dip next time they bring em out. It’s like I’m eating two at once. Of course you can’t sleep on the others like Cookie Dough and Cannoli. All of these are top 10 for good reason, they are the elites.

11 🍫 CHOCOLATE MILKSHAKE
12 BIRTHDAY CAKE FT. OREO®
13 ❄️ FROZEN HOT CHOCOLATE
14 🍨 SKILLET COOKIE
15 BROWNIE SUNDAE
16 COOKIE BUTTER ICE CREAM FT. BISCOFF®
17 🌋 COOKIE BUTTER LAVA FT. BISCOFF®
18 🍫 CHOCOLATE CAKE BATTER
19 SEMI-SWEET CHOCOLATE CHUNK
20 MILK CHOCOLATE CHIP

More elites over here. The classic chocolate chip may feel a bit low btu that’s just how good a lot of these other cookies are. I will eat all of these in a heartbeat so you shouldn’t have any worries about cookie quality or anything like that.

21 PEANUT BUTTER CUP FT. REESE’S
22 CHOCOLATE SPRINKLE
23 CHOCOLATE CRUMB FT. OREO®️
24 COOKIES & CREAM
25 CHOCOLATE COOKIES & CREAM
26 🥜 🍫 PEANUT BUTTER COOKIES & CREAM
27 🥜 CHOCOLATE PEANUT BUTTER FT. OREO®
28 CONFETTI MILKSHAKE
29 🥧 BOSTON CREAM PIE
30 🌗 Brookie

The Reese’s angle helps put the peanut butter cup above most of the other peanut butter flavors. Biting into a cup at the top really makes all the difference and tastes absolutely amazing! Don’t underestimate Chocolate Sprinkle either, really great stuff right there.

31 BROWNIE BATTER
32 FRIED ICE CREAM
33 ❄️ FROZEN HOT CHOCOLATE
34 🥧 BROOKIE DOUGH PIE
35 🧁 CHOCOLATE CUPCAKE
36 🌀 CHOCOLATE SWISS ROLL
37 CHOCOLATE PEANUT BUTTER CHIP
38 👻 MONSTER FT. M&M’S® CANDIES
39 Original featuring M&M’s® Candies (Valentines)
40 🔴 ORIGINAL FT. M&M’S® CANDIES

Fried Ice Cream is a real novelty pick for sure. It feels nice to eat that in cookie form and I love M&Ms so all of those variations tend to be really high. You just can’t go wrong there.

41 CHOCOLATE MILK
42 CHOCOLATE CARAMEL
43 PEANUT BUTTER MUNCH FT. MUDDY BUDDIES™️
44 🥜 CHOCOLATE PEANUT BUTTER PUFFS
45 🥜 CHOCOLATE PEANUT BUTTER PIE
46 🥜 PEANUT BUTTER FT. REESE’S PIECES
47 🍫 CHOCOLATE CAKE (LTO)
48 CHOCOLATE CAKE (Cookie)
49 🔴 ORIGINAL FT. PEANUT BUTTER M&M’S® CANDIES
50 MOLTEN LAVA

Not much more to say on this one, we’re still looking at absolutely top tier chocolate and peanut butter flavors. All of these are absolute winners and you could make great cases for them to be even higher.

51 FRENCH SILK PIE
52 COOKIE BUTTER WHITE CHIP FT. BISCOFF®
53 DARK DREAM
54 🍁 MAPLE CREAM SANDWICH
55 🥛 COOKIES & CREAM CHEESECAKE (LTO)
56 🟤 FRENCH SILK PIE
57 🥛 COOKIES & CREAM PIE
58 🍒 BLACK FOREST CAKE
59 MALLOW CREME FT. LUCKY CHARMS®
60 PEANUT BUTTER BROWNIE

Another really solid array of snacks. The Maple Cream Sandwich was so rich that it can hold its own with all of these big chocolate flavors.

61 PEANUT BUTTER CRISP FT. BUTTERFINGER®
62 🥛 COOKIES & CREAM TRES LECHES CAKE
63 🎁 EGGNOG TRES LECHES CAKE
64 🥛 TRES LECHES CAKE FT LOTUS BISCOFF (LTO)
65 🍰 TRES LECHES CAKE
66 S’MORES
67 PEANUT BUTTER CREME FT. NUTTER BUTTER®
68 CAKE BATTER BLONDIE
69 CAKE BATTER
70 🥇 VANILLA CRUMB CAKE FT. GOLDEN OREO®

The blondie flavors may be lacking in chocolate but they still taste really fun to me. The Thres Leche may feel a bit low since I love the cake a lot but they could stand to be a bit sweeter. Still a lot of fun of course.

71 🧂 SALTED CARAMEL CHEESECAKE
72 BUCKEYE BROWNIE
73 🍎 APPLE PIE
74 👻 THE AFTERLIFE CAKE (LTO)
75 DIRT CAKE
76 BUTTERSCOTCH CHIP
77 MONSTER
78 DULCE DE LECHE
79 ✨ SNICKERDOODLE SANDWICH
80 ⚪ RED VELVET WHITE CHIP

We’re starting to lose a tiny bit of momentum but if you bought these cookies for anyone they’d be thrilled. Also it was cool to see Crumbls throw their hat in the ring for the apple pie. They really put up a good effort for it I gotta say.

81 🎃 PUMPKIN BROWNIE
82 NEW YORK CHEESECAKE
83 🍁 MAPLE CINNAMON SQUARE (LTO)
84 🟫 CINNAMON SQUARE
85 🍁 MAPLE CINNAMON ROLL
86 KENTUCKY BUTTER CAKE
87 🥛 CINNAMON CRUNCH
88 VANILLA GLAZE FT. CINNAMON TOAST CRUNCH™
89 🍓 FROSTED STRAWBERRY FT. POP-TARTS®
90 NEAPOLITAN

The Pumpkin Brownie looks so rich! Some really fun ones here and shoutout to the Kentucky Butter Cake because that could have been ultra generic and weak but it ended up tasting super good.

91 CHOCOLATE COVERED STRAWBERRY
92 🧂 SALTED CARAMEL CHEESECAKE (LTO)
93 🟠 Pumpkin Cheesecake
94 🔲 COOKIES & CREAM KRISPY BAR
95 CLASSIC KRISPIES BAR FT. RICE KRISPIES®
96 SUGAR (GOLD COIN)
97 SUGAR FT. MOTHER’S® CIRCUS ANIMAL™️
98 SUGAR (CANDY EGGS)
99 🦈 SUGAR SHARK FT. SHARK WEEK™
100 VANILLA SUGAR (HALLOWEEN)

The sugar cookies take over here! You can’t go wrong with a good sugar cookie. They may be basic but at the end of the day they still get the job done as needed.

101 🧈 BUTTER CAKE
102 CARAMEL CAKE
103 BIRTHDAY CAKE
104 🎊 CONFETTI CAKE (LTO)
105 MAPLE GLAZE
106 MILK GLAZE FT. FRUITY PEBBLES™
107 🍏 APPLE CRUMB CAKE
108 🌀 CINNAMON ROLL
109 RED VELVET CUPCAKE
110 ❤️✨ WONKA’S WILDLY WONDERFUL RED VELVETY COOKIE

Butter Cake is a basic but fun flavor. These flavors are all a bit on the basic side but help you appreciate the more complex flavors above. These are what really helped to set the stage after all!

111 🍞 FRENCH TOAST
112 BUTTERMILK PANCAKE
113 WAFFLE
114 ULTIMATE PEANUT BUTTER
115 CLASSIC PEANUT BUTTER
116 💗 Pink Velvet Cake (Cookie)
117 🩷 PINK VELVET CAKE (LTO)
118 HONEY CAKE FT. TEDDY GRAHAMS®
119 HONEY BUN
120 CINNAMON FRYBREAD

This batch has a lot of what I would call “Sugar with a twist” cookies. You’ve got different breakfast combos, cinnamon, honey, peanut butter, and even some pink velvet jumping in. These are all really solid cookies and it’s pretty nice to see that even over 100 items into the list we’re talking high quality. I could eat any of these right now and feel pretty good about it.

121 🎃 PUMPKIN ROLL
122 🟤 BROWN SUGAR CINNAMON FT. POP-TARTS®
123 🎃 CARAMEL PUMPKIN CAKE
124 🥧 PUMPKIN PIE
125 🎃 PUMPKIN CAKE (LTO)
126 🥨 CHOCOLATE COVERED PRETZEL PIE
127 🟠 GINGERSNAP
128 CHURRO
129 COTTON CANDY
130 NILLA BEAN CUPCAKE

These cookies aren’t bad but they’re a bit generic. Pumpkin Roll looks really good but didn’t have a ton of flavor. Same for the Churro and Gingersnap cookies. They’ll definitely help to satisfy your appetite and you won’t have any problem eating them but it’s clear that these weren’t quite ready for the big time.

131 STRAWBERRY CUPCAKE
132 STRAWBERRY CAKE
133 SNICKERDOODLE
134 SNICKERDOODLE CUPCAKE
135 ROCKY ROAD
136 PINK DOUGHNUT
137 OLD FASHIONED DOUGHNUT
138 TEXAS SHEET CAKE
139 🍏 APPLE CIDER MUFFIN
140 🟠 PUMPKIN CHOCOLATE CHIP

These are flavors to eat in a pinch but they wouldn’t be your first choice. They all have some kind of catch like the Texas Sheet cake which has good chocolate flavor but the nuts get in the way. The pumpkin dough didn’t go particularly well with the chocolate chips either. Good concepts for some of these items but the execution really wasn’t there.

141 MINT BROWNIE
142 CLASSIC PINK SUGAR
143 🟤 PECAN CHOCOLATE CHIP
144 🍋 LEMON CAKE (LTO)
145 🍃 MINT MALLOW SANDWICH
146 MINT CHIP ICE CREAM
147 MACADAMIA NUT
148 🍃 CHOCOLATE GREEN MINT
149 🍦 PEPPERMINT ICE CREAM
150 RASPBERRY CHEESECAKE

We’re starting to really reach the dicey flavors now. The Classic Pink Sugar was surprisingly bad since I generally like sugar cookies a lot. I’ve heard that the icing is almond based so I guess the almonds that they used weren’t really up my alley. Then you’ve got a bunch of mint and fruits that start to falter. I’m afraid Crumbls is over the hill by this point and these are flavors to avoid.

151 BLUEBERRY CHEESECAKE
152 🍫 CHOCOLATE TOFFEE CAKE
153 🌊 CHOCOLATE SEA SALT TOFFEE
154 SEA SALT TOFFEE
155 MOM’S RECIPE
156 ❤️🤍 CANDY CANE BROWNIE
157 LEMON CREAM PIE
158 🍋🧁 LEMON CUPCAKE
159 🍋 LEMON CRINKLE
160 LEMON BAR

Lots of toffee and lemon here which are not winning combinations. Maybe if you really toned down the strength of the flavors then some of these could work but I don’t think you could do much to fix them. Toffee just has a unique feel to it after all and I imagine lemon fans wouldn’t want a weakened version of their cookie. Puts them in a tough spot.

161 🌾 OATMEAL MALLOW SANDWICH
162 🥧 KEY LIME PIE
163 LEMONADE
164 MAPLE OATMEAL
165 🍌 BANOFFEE PIE
166 BANANA BREAD

Well we’re at the end now. None of these are cookies that I would go for. If any of them were given to me for free I would have a hard time eating them. They’re just not my cup of tea but power to you if you like them of course. The worst of all time has to go to Banana Bread. It’s a dubious honor but the taste just doesn’t work for me. It’s even stronger than Lemon and the other flavors that I’m not big on.

So that’s it! I’m sure I’ll reach 200 flavors at some point as they keep on going. Can a new flavor ever crack the top 10? It’ll be difficult to be sure but I’m eager to see how it goes. I’ll do something like this for Insomnia Cookies and Chip City some day when I’ve tried enough flavors as well. Of course the more flavors there are, the tougher it gets to do these. Even on this list I’m sure if you look hard enough there will be some placements that don’t make sense and I would shift them but at least to the best of my ability I would say this is the definitive list.