Bart Simpson is pretty tough and all, but can he win this round? He has his cupcakes and his alternate identities, but in the end they may not be enough. Beavis seems like more of a fighter. He’ll land some good shots in and show the world why he takes the win. Beavis wins.
With his guns, Bart now takes the win here. Bart Simpson wins.
DReager1.com 
I would argue that, with the composite rule, alternate realities (like the Halloween specials) are counted here, so Bart had this even before these guns (which ones are you thinking of?). Like that one special where Bart was a wizard, or the other one where he was a vampire, or the one where he turned Homer into a jack-in-the-box with his mind (amongst other things). What’s Beavis got?
Right, I just had a tough time finding out much about what he could do in those specials. I vaguely know about the vampire for example, but didn’t know what he could do in that form. It’s true that those count and that he theoretically didn’t even need the guns to win. Still, when I made the match, I couldn’t find anything to really help Bart so Beavis initially ended up winning because he’s physically a little tougher. He has no guns or anything as far as I know. As for which guns, I don’t know the specifics of it, just that Bart’s used them in the past.