This is definitely a tough battle as both opponents are fairly similar in their abilities. Both of them have many conventional weapons. While Connor seems to be slightly faster in combat, Edward may have the better weapons. It would be a close fight, but I like to think that Edward would be able to win this battle. He just seems to be a little more experienced in these showdowns and the armor will help to make this more of a close range battle. Again, this is a really close fight though! Edward Kenway wins.
DReager1.com 
im not criticising, but you have to understand, when i requested this battle, i was wishing connor would win. still a great fight. i think connor would win because he’s much younger then edward. edward is a great fighter, but connor has more stamina. on the other hand, edward could use his guns at a good range, and connor has a bow, but i don’t think it would be good in a ranged battle. still, thank you for accepting my request.
Haha, well I’ve definitely seen a lot of backfires in my day. It’s bound to happen sometimes. Connor is definitely a great fighter and I do think that it could really go either way, but I feel like Edward may have the slight edge in combat with his experience. His armor should also help against Connor’s bow and arrow.