All right, it’s time for Superman to finally claim a victory. Hagrid may have some decent strength at his disposal, but it won’t be enough to deal with the Man of Steel. Superman’s superior speed and intellect will ensure that he doesn’t fall for any of Hagrid’s combos. Hagrid couldn’t endure a single hit from Superman and there’s no way that he can dodge forever. He will have lost the round before a minute would have passed. Superman wins.
DReager1.com 
I imagine Superman should be able to dodge it or what have you, but it still strikes me as odd that Hagrid’s magic wasn’t brought up what with Superman explicitly being vulnerable to magic
That’s true, Superman is vulnerable to magic, but Hagrid’s abilities are incredibly mild and he barely has any attack spells. He can summon fire and all, but Superman just needs one good sneeze to blow up the planet or a blast of Heat Vision to take Hagrid down for the count.