Suggested by Jimmy Biscuits Popeye can throw a mean punch all right. I think I speak for everyone when I say that a fight between him and Rocky could be a lot of fun. That being said, Popeye is a little outmatched here. Little Mac is very fast so he’s good at landing a flurry of blows and dodging the counters. Furthermore, he has his Giga Mac form to back him up if things get tough. With or without powers, Little Mac is just the better fighter in the end. Little Mac wins.