Suggested by JHG This is a pretty close fight between two happy girls who try to do their best in a tough world. One big difference though is that Penny is 6 years old while Madeline is 7. Neither one of them has a lot of fighting experience, but Madeline seemed pretty sure of herself in the live action film. I believe she was also aged up to 10 in that film as well which helps quite a bit. Penny puts up a brave fight, but it won’t be enough. Madeline wins.