Julian is a commander from Gen Lock who has the ability to mind meld with a robot and fight that way. As a result he is a pretty tough fighter and that puts him above Thane. Otherwise the two would probably be a pretty even match in terms of hand to hand combat. Thane has his energy blasters, but I don’t think that can even hope to counter a giant mech. Ultimately this is Julian’s match to lose and I don’t think he will crumble under the pressure. Julian Chase wins.