This is a match of weak main characters. Allen (I can’t even begin to describe how weak he is) is just a sad character. Edward is the generic main character who knows alchemy. Sadly alchemy isn’t a really good power. Actually it can be a great power Edward just never uses it right. Sadly even he can beat Allen. Edward wins.

DR

Since this was last written, things have changed. Allen has gotten 2 power ups and a big sword. Edward has also gotten a powerup but it’s pretty cheap. Allen wins.