Seto Kaiba is one of the strongest people on the planet. His might is matched only by his intelligence. He was able to invent a new way of dueling and how to make playing children’s card games more fun. His cards would take down Superman. While Superman may be able to beat A Blue Eyes White Dragon, Kaiba has 3. Even if he beat those 3 he has Obelisk The Tormenter. While Superman is very strong he will wear down against Kaiba. Kaiba has over 50 cards at his disposal. Kaiba wins.
DReager1.com 
If holograms created by machines were to ever do actual damage to superman superman would STILL win because there would be no more kryptonite on the planet. Superman destroyed it all. (Cept for the bit that batman carries.)
The Thing is that Kaiba can use real monsters in the end that would take down Superman
Uh…How do fake hologram monsters hurt a physical being? Just what? Sure he can stomp other card users’ monsters because they are also hologram monsters. If you say they are real, I need proof like a scan of them hurting a human, a real human that uses cards, not other monsters.
Well, for all intents and purposes, the cards are real in his fights. It’s similar to other toyetic shows where the weapons and cards may not be real, I make them real to give the fighters a fighting chance. Also, the virtual duels do typically seem to cause the duelists some pain and stress.
Based on Yugioh logic, Superman would beat Kaiba outside of the game. As for stress, its because a competitive atmosphere can be stressful for most people.
True, but the game physically hurts them even when it’s an illusion a lot of the time. Superman can try to speedblitz Kaiba, but Obelisk The Tormentor should be able to grab Superman and stop that from happening.