The Villager was definitely a shocking addition to the Super Smash roster, but I can’t say that I really care for his moveset so far. I’m sure that it’ll be a lot better on the Wii U version of course, but Shulk definitely has the massive advantage here. His energy sword works on any console and he has experience on his side. A few good hits should knock the Villager out of the runnings here. Shulk wins.