This is certainly a classic battle. Dark Vader always appeared to have the edge over Luke in their battles. Luke continued to grow stronger as a Jedi Master though and as Dark Vader has not been around in a while, he has not been able to do the same. So, did Luke ever actually surpass Dark Vader or has he reached his limit? I’d actually argue that Dark Vader is still Luke’s superior and especially when you consider that Luke stopped training for a very long time. Any potential that Luke may have had is certainly long gone now. Luke is a formidable fighter and that will not change, but I believe Dark Vader to be superior with his force abilities and also deadlier with his Lightsaber. He’s pulled off feats far greater than Luke’s and his knowledge of the light and the dark will serve him well. Perhaps Luke will change my mind in Episode VIII. Dark Vader wins.
DReager1.com 
I agree that Vader would probably win but I think Luke might have a chance. If I remember correctly from the movie, when Vader mentioned about Leia, Luke got mad and attacked with rage and cut off his arm. Personally, I pick Luke.
You can certainly make a fair case for Luke. He is the avatar of the Light after all so in theory, he should be able to take out the Dark’s commander. Their fights were definitely a lot of fun back in the day.
Yeah the fight was most impressive. Luke and Vader are two sides of the coin of light and dark.
Guys…I’m not Kim Kardashian…but…..this is a rlly good post. Vader would definitely though…lol….cool post tho….ur awesome.
thx
Before ep 7 luke. after what happened in ep 8 darth vader
Yeah Darth Vader’s got too many skills to go down at this point