Villager really got popular thanks to being in the Super Smash Bros game and I will admit that I’m impressed that he got into the club. It’s always good to see a new fighter and while I don’t like to play as him, his moveset is strong. That being said, Cloud would definitely crush him in a fight. He’s faster, stronger, and has more attack options. There’s really no argument to be made for Villager (That I’m aware of) and Cloud would just need one high speed slice to end this. Cloud wins.