Suggested by iKnowledge Mercutio is always ready for a fight despite being a practical jokester. He’s clearly practiced in secret while Ancient Pistol is afraid to get into action. He avoids it whenever possible so I have to assume that he’s just not very good. Mercutio should have no problem slicing him into defeat. There just isn’t room for two swordsmen in this ring so someone has to take the fall. Mercutio wins.