Suggested by Sonic Petey Piranha is a pretty powerful Mario villain and I’m actually surprised that he had not fought on the blog prior to this as all of the other Piranhas had. (Dino Piranha, Piranha Plant, Peewee Piranha, etc) Piranha Plant is a tough fighter and all, but he’s definitely not quite in the same league as Petey Piranha. Petey can swing his cages with immense power and also has a lot of durability. There’s no way a normal plant can stop him. Petey Piranha wins.
DReager1.com 
Petey Piranha definitely. He can move around and he is a giant plant.
Absolutely, his size will be really helpful here. A single hit would end the fight
Yeah and as far I know, I remember Mario first fought this guy in Super Mario Sunshine more than once. I am not sure if a small plant will be able to win against a giant walking planet.