Suggested by iKnowledge Both of these guys are pretty tough fighters. They can wield a blade exceptionally well and have some super strength as well. When you mix those two attributes together then you’ve got a very dangerous fighter. I think I’d go with Caramon Majere having the edge here though. Beowulf has taken down a dragon and a monster in the past, but overall I think he’d be more likely to get hit by one of Caramon’s strikes. That would very quickly end the battle. Caramon Majere wins.