Suggested by iKnowledge Maya Natsume seems a little more impressive than Aya to be sure, but I still wouldn’t say that she is quite ready to take down Erza. Erza has a lot of battle experience at her disposal including a large array of different armors to choose from. Erza’s stats are above Maya’s and she will be able to dodge Natsume’s attacks with ease. Erza’s been around the block quite a few times in her prime. She’ll be able to definitely outlast Maya when it comes to stamina. Erza wins.