Alan is one of those guys who isn’t eager to fight but he can do so as needed. Jed may be a genius but he doesn’t have the physical abilities needed to take on someone who has mastered sound. Alan can make his sound work in such an offensive manner that it can shatter monsters. There’s no way Jed can get out of earshot so one hit will take him out here. Jed would need a big sci-fi boost to have any kind of chance here. Alan Blackman wins.