Suggested by iKnowledge Maki definitely has the edge in pure hand to hand combat skills but I wouldn’t say that this is by a large margin. Batgirl is close enough where her gadgets will make up the difference and then some. It’s why gadgets are so useful in a fight like this. Hastily thrown they can end up being a liability but Batgirl is just as good at using those as she is at fighting. Ultimately that means Maki will be out of luck here. Batgirl wins.