Suggested by Anonymous I could see Marco putting up more of a fight than some of Whitebeard’s other challengers but there is a reason why Whitebeard was the captain. He’s much more powerful and Marco’s main weakness is a lack of offensive capabilities. That’s not a weakness that Whitebeard shares and so he will be able to really accelerate to the top of the rankings. No fighter can hope to keep up with his monstrous strength. Whitebeard wins.