Both of these Marios are defintiely winners and they never back down from a fight. I’d still be inclined to go with Mario in this round, given his battle experience and his determination to never give up. In his star form, Mario’s definitely a dangerous adversary. I don’t think that Mario Auditore could stop him. Mario wins.
DReager1.com 
Thank you. Mario would win. I just wanted to see this battle because they are both named Mario. I’ve got a few more requests.
Ash vs Gary
Misty vs Dawn
Both requests are accepted. It’ll mark the first time that Gary’s ever fought on the blog!