Comic Reviews, Comics, Reviews

Transformers vs GI Joe Review

It’s time for another one of the Free comics from this year’s event. This comic is the start of a whole new series where these two popular franchises will duke it out. Since it is the first issue; we don’t get to see them fight all that much, but it is the set up. It also serves as an alternate retelling for both sides so that the continuity fit. Unfortunately, the art and character personalities take the comic down a few notches.

The plot involves the Joes as they are taking down a Cobra base and thoroughly enjoying it. None of them are actually taking it seriously, but Cobra is still pretty confident since things are going according to plan. The plan changes a little because Bumblebee and Starscream are duking it out. The Decepticon has a pretty huge advantage and explosions ripple across the area. Will the Joes be able to finish off Cobra Commander and still have enough energy left to take on a Decepticon?

The plot itself is decent, but the dialogue can be a little painful. Duke and Snake Eyes spend most of their screen time flirting with Scarlet. It’s sad enough that such an epic commander like Duke would be doing this while on a mission of life and death, but Snake Eyes? Snake Eyes is supposed to be the quiet and tough ninja that does what must be done. Not only does he ditch the mask, but Snake Eyes talks a lot. He makes many puns and jokes while showing off the fact that he’s not as professional as he used to be. Snake Eyes gets a lot of hype for his reasoning skills, but then he throws an ordinary grenade at a huge robot. I don’t believe that this was a very smart move.

The ending is pretty sad for the heroes. Bumblebee has a pretty sad fate in store for him and the Joes have a man down. Hopefully, Duke will bounce back from this and look good again. That way, the rest of the Joes can follow suit. The first issue is supposed to make you want to pick up the series, but I can’t say that this one did anything for me. It just wasn’t that fun to read.

The artwork is pretty bad and at times it feels as if it’s a fan comic. I really have to say that the art is some of the most underwhelming that I have seen in ages and the bandages scene was particularly hard to look at. I actually had to make sure that this was the official comic as I was reading it. Art is something that can really help a comic if done right and these drawings just bring the issue down.

Overall, Transformers vs GI Joe may have just been called GI Joe: Attack on Cobra! The Transformers cross paths with the Joes for a second, but they’re mainly involved in completely different plots. Naturally, this is because it’s only the first issue, but it doesn’t change the fact that we didn’t get a whole lot of interaction. I wouldn’t pick up the next issues based on this one and I definitely wouldn’t recommend it to the casual reader. Start off with the Transformers and New Avengers crossover instead.

Overall 5/10


3 thoughts on “Transformers vs GI Joe Review”

  1. I may take a peak at this out of curiosity. Crossovers can be fun, even if the end result is only so-so. I remember watching a later episode of Transformers back in the 80s that took place in the time when Rodimus Prime and Galvatron were around. It actually had Cobra Commander in it and I just thought the whole thing was awesome and made me hope for more. =)

    1. I definitely agree that crossovers are great. I believe that they had a few previous meet ups in the comics, but this is the first time that I got to read one. If you can get past the art; then the rest of the comic isn’t that bad so it can still be a decent read. They were giving it away on Free Comic Book Day so it should still be free or really cheap to purchase. I probably wouldn’t get the series when it comes out, but renting the trade paperback once a few issues have been collected definitely sounds like a plan.

      Crossing those two franchises together is definitely something that Hasbro should consider doing more often. After all, they own both series so the usual copyright issues wouldn’t be a problem. It would be fun to see them team up on screen. I may vaguely remember the Cobra Commander cameo (If he appeared inside of a TV screen then I remember him. If not, then I must have forgotten that cameo..which is pretty sad!) but I’m not certain.

  2. If I remember correct, this is going to be an ongoing series, not just a mini-series. So it needs some background stuff to happen, even these are very far from the classic crossover style. Great article though and I think too that this was a mediocre attempt for a first issue.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.