Suggested by Anon Carl Johnson may be good at driving but that doesn’t mean that he can fight an army of monsters. Let’s face it, Yami Yugi would actually have a good chance at beating Carl in a race as well since he is such a natural talent. It’s just hard to defeat someone like that. Of course, this is a fight and not a race so that makes the outcome a little less debatable. Yami Yugi wins.