Suggested by iKnowledge While Aya doesn’t enter combat nearly as much as her sister, she is still quite proficient at it. Once again it is a question of whether or not Lucy’s guardians can hold their own before Aya breaks the line. As it stands, I just don’t think that they can. I’ve never been particularly impressed with Lucy’s guardians and it’s just so hard to protect Lucy when Aya’s attacks can come from close or long range. If Lucy could learn to fight a little more then this match could easily change. Aya Natsume wins.
DReager1.com 
The Celestial Spirit Summoner takes this. Lucy is endurance incarnate and has a diverse disposal of spirits. And for the record, I find them powerful. You’re massively underselling their importance.
I admit that I’ve never been too impressed with her spirits. They just don’t seem all that powerful compared with most of the other characters in Fairy Tail. Their sheer strength would end this match, but I don’t think Lucy could pull that off
I’m sure she could; who’s the other girl?
She’s from Tenjou Tenge. I’m not all that familiar with the franchise though