Suggested by Destroyer Trust me when I say that I’m not the biggest Frodo fan out there but he probably still takes this match rather easily. Derpy isn’t a fighter in any sense of the word and doesn’t have any great physical abilities that would turn the tides here. At least Frodo has his invisibility cloak but at the end of the day what does Derpy really have? She can fly rather quickly but that’s about it and so Frodo is going to take this with one stab from his short sword. Frodo wins.