Suggested by iKnowledge Hercules is a pretty powerful fighter. While he has never been in the same league as Thor, the guy puts a lot of passion behind every punch. He’s not a fighter that you should take lightly. That being said, Guts is highly proficient with his sword so he’ll have the edge in mid range combat and the difference in their speed isn’t even comparable. Hercules won’t be landing any hits here. Guts wins.
DReager1.com 
Due to Hercules being the spawn of a Skyfather in Marvel Comics, I still think he has a chance against Guts. Guts is not a half-god like he is.
True, Guts doesn’t have that stature but he’s definitely done quite well for himself over the years and I do think that Hercules is probably outmatched physically at the very least