Gregor Clegane vs Gotrek Gurnisson



GotrekMarkGibbons
Suggested by iKnowledge Both of these fighters possess super strength and prefer close quarters combat. Gregor uses a long sword while Gotrek has an axe. Gregor certainly has the better weapon when it comes to range, but Gotrek’s hammer would break it if they collided. I give Gregor the edge here because he should still be able to land some decisive blows while avoiding a weapon hit. Even if his sword does shatter, he can likely snatch Gotrek’s weapon away and then finish him off. Gregor Clegane wins.

Advertisements

8 thoughts on “Gregor Clegane vs Gotrek Gurnisson

  1. I believe Gotrek has a chance. Warhammer Dwarves should have speed and skill advantages over ASOIAF characters, and what could stop Gotrek’s axe from becoming a deliverer of the Square-Cube law and sending Gregor tumbling, despite the latter’s speed? At that point, what could stop Gregor’s head from being split open with the Axe-Blade?

    • I definitely don’t deny that he has a chance here. It was a pretty close fight. I think the tough part here would be the speed. I feel like Gregor’s agile enough to parry Gotrek and land some good stabs in. He could potentially even catch the axe by the handle when Gotrek tries to hit him and that would work pretty well as a counter. I think that would be Gregor’s best bet here

      • Thank you for confirming my suspicions that you don’t have the slightest clue what you’re talking about. So basically you have no idea about Gotrek’s capabilities and feats, but Gregor Clegane wins because yes, right? Lol.

        Gotrek has killed (among other things, but the list is too long to post here) an ancestral Chaos giant in single combat and is strong enough to resist the giant’s grip when it tried to crush him in its hand, it doesn’t matter if Gotrek’s equipment is just a loincloth and he goes against a fully armed and armored Gregor Clegane, the dwarf will still win.

      • Well, I quickly took a peak at Gotrek’s wiki page and didn’t really see anything all that impressive for him. The Giant feat sounds pretty good for sure, can you recall when that happened so I can quickly fact check it. After confirming I believe that would be enough to overturn the match so then I would quickly do that.

      • The giant thing happens in Giantslayer (unsurprisingly). In fact you can take any of the Gotreka and Felix books to find ample proof that he is vastly superior to anyone in ASOIAF.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.