Suggested by Dinosaurroars Lucifer Magne may sound a lot more impressive than Shaggy right off the bat but Shaggy has the advantage of having been around in media for many decades. As a result he has gained quite a few super abilities in his day like that time he got Shazam’s abilities. Of course that doesn’t suddenly mean he’s as strong as Shazam and we didn’t get to see him do much but Shaggy still got a degree of super strength, speed, and flight. That’s enough to take down Lucifer who really didn’t get a chance to do much of anything. Shaggy wins.