Alphonse and Edward were always pretty tough fighters. Together there aren’t many fighters who can take them down! Alphonse has a lot of raw power and with it he pwns a lot of opponents. Of course Edward is faster and better at hand to hand combat.

Alphonse may be less athletic, but considering that he’s in a suit of armor it’s understandable. Edward has also witnessed true power and even used some of it at the end of the series. Alphonse is just a bit out of his league in this match. He was close, but in the end there’s a reason that Edward’s the main character. Edward wins.