Both of these fighters are close combat specialists. Asagi is from Witchblade while Aldra is from the rival, Queensblade. Typically, I would expect Witchblade characters to be much higher tier. That being said, it seems like Asagi never really gets to fight and mostly relies on hype. Aldra doesn’t have the greatest abilities, but she does have multiple blades and I assume that her speed is around Asagi’s level so she should be able to claim a narrow victory. Aldra wins.