Suggested by iKnowledge Sam and Phoebe are certainly no strangers to magic. Phoebe has augmented strength and defense as well as speed. She’s a capable all around fighter who may not be a fighter by nature but can really hold her own in a match. In the other corner you’ve got Sam who has so many powers it is hard to list them all. This fight really boils down to the fact that his healing factor is considerably better than Phoebe’s and he is a better fighter. She won’t be able to get past him. Sam Winchester wins.