Suggested by iKnowledge It’s time for a battle of two Game of Throne characters. Randyll is a capable commander who knows how to lead his troops around, but in combat I don’t think he would have the speed or stamina needed to defeat Stannis. Stannis has seen his share of battlegrounds and knows how to fight as well as lead. Randyll could probably give him a good run for his money and in a battle of mortals one stab is all that either side needs to win. I think Stannis would get the critical blow though. Stannis Baratheon wins.