This is a tribute to The Last Witch Hunter. Kaulder may do a decent job when it comes to stopping witches in his world, but he wouldn’t last long against the threats that Maka has to deal with. One of her attacks is a real Witch Hunter and one shot would take Kaulder down for the count. Physically, he is still just a normal joe so he wouldn’t be able to keep up with her speed for a single minute. Maka wins.