Suggested by iKnowledge It’s time for a battle of tough guys who both know how to fire a gun pretty accurately. Richard Sharpe has a lot of durability as he has survived injuries that would have destroyed most. He’s had part of his skull crushed and been stabbed many times, but he never gives up. On the other hand Gaston has some mild super strength and he is a very talented hunter. I don’t think Richard would be able to win here as he might endure the pounding for a little while, but he just isn’t strong enough to counter attack. Gaston wins.