Sonic Memories and Beyond Review


Recently the Sonic franchise has been doing well with its multi media approach and this special was no exception. We finally get to see what Sonic is really capable of when he’s not holding back thanks to Metal Sonic being the main villain here. The special is quick of course but is still absolutely amazing from start to finish. This is the kind of short that you are going to want to watch more than once. The production values are through the roof.

The premise itself is fairly basic. Sonic and team head to Eggman’s base to stop him from his latest attempt to take over the world. Eggman has prepared Metal Sonic to stop them but Sonic laughs this off since he brought Shadow and other powerhouses. What Sonic didn’t expect was that Eggman had a plan for this. Metal Sonic begins copying Sonic’s life force and is now moving at crazy high speeds. When force is not enough, Sonic and friends must try a more emotional approach here.

Right away I can tell you that the animation is absolutely striking. The characters look great, the action is top tier, the movement is phenomenal, etc. We haven’t had many chances to see Sonic characters moving like this. They go so fast that you even need to slow down the video in order to notice the smaller details like Knuckles getting pinballed from an earlier punch throughout Metal’s whole fight with Amy, or Shadow actually fighting an after image of Metal for part of the fight while the real one is behind him.

The animation is using every trick in the book to show just how fast he is. It’s really impressive and reason 1 million on why I would take Sonic over the Flash any day. You have to remember that for the first half of the video, Metal is just using Sonic’s life force so this is all stuff that he could do already. Then in the second half it is Super Sonic’s power which is naturally above the rest of the cast. It was great to just see him styling on everyone while also acknowledging that the only character who can even come close to matching him is Shadow. Shadow is the only one putting up a proper fight and that’s how it should be. Keep in mind that Shadow keeps his limiters on for this fight so he may still be worried that going all out could hurt someone in the background.

The flashbacks are also fun as we see a lot of classic moments from the Sonic mythos. Sonic was always an inspiration to everyone and getting to relive that is always fun. That being said, it does make for a climax that isn’t very satisfying. You want to see just how Sonic and friends will manage to defeat Metal Sonic, not talking him down from fighting. I would have preferred Tails find a way to turn Sonic super and then we get a big clash. I get what the special is going for with nostalgia but I will take straight action any day!

Now there has been a lot of discussion about Sonic’s smile near the end and how he talks about friendship so much. Ultimately I’m cool with it because Sonic is a character who does get emotional sometimes. He could probably stand to be a little quieter and letting the speed do the talking but you could also interpret it as Sonic just taking more of a leadership role like how he tries to keep Tails from worrying about him as the pain sets in. Sonic is always good as internalizing stuff like that and his biggest speech was all in his head. So we’re just getting an extra close look at Sonic.

The more valid critique is that Sonic was essentially sidelined for the whole fight. Because of how the life drain worked, he was out of speed and power for pretty much the whole special. He got one good combo in but otherwise Metal was just styling on him the whole time. The scene of Metal walking alongside Sonic is sure to send chills to anyone around. That was a scene that is hard to get past and no character is winning a fight when the speed gap is this great.

The special really proves my case on why speed is the most important attribute in a fight. Bar none, there are no other attributes that can top that. If you have a sufficient advantage in speed then you are going to always win the fight. That’s just how it goes and honestly that’s not a bad thing. I love watching a good speed blitz and this special had a whole lot of those. We really need a full Sonic show in this style one day. That would be the best!

Overall, This was absolutely terrific and I hope Sega continues to churn these out. I know we have a racing special coming up so maybe that can be on this level as well. There have been a lot of great Sonic specials over the recent years like the Shadow trilogy. Sega has clearly got their finger on something good and they just need to keep on going. Hopefully we also get a new Sonic game at some point too because we are long overdue on that. Putting Metal Sonic as the villain would certainly be exciting since he is also going to be the villain of the new movie coming up.

Overall 9/10