Sword Art Online Progressive Canon of The Golden Rule Review


It’s time for another Sword Art online Progressive title. This one has the characters going through a bit more of a peaceful adventure for once. The first volume has a big fight but after that it is more about setup. The pacing can feel a bit odd for this one but I suppose that’s eventually bound to happen when you have a short manga spinoff for each adventure. These 2 volumes have to try their best to tell a complete story which isn’t easy since there is no ending yet. It’s probably one of the most sudden endings you will see in a manga, outside of titles that were literally cancelled.

The title starts with Kirito and Asuna continuing to gradually climb up the tower. They are doing it at their own pace though and for now feel no pressure to join the advance army. They will continue with their dark elf quest as well as take in the sights. Kirito and Asuna even get to check out some new food at a ritzy restaurant. Unfortunately journeys in SAO are never without some kind of danger and a random side quest ends up putting them in the crosshairs of the PKers.

I gotta say this felt a bit sloppy for Kirito. Now, I get that you can’t be paranoid 100% of the time about people trying to show up and murder you but agreeing to do a side quest where you get paralyzed for a while is a pretty bad idea. I blame the devs for this as well since you should at least make sure that the NPCs are near invincible to protect the players. They get easily crushed by the PKers who aren’t even at a super high level yet.

Relatively speaking, this is pretty early on in the SAO adventure after all. So Kirito gets some heat from me for doing the quest but the game itself gets some heat for having a quest that puts you in such danger. I expected better from Kayaba, the creator of the game. Naturally there are a lot of people who would want to be PKs who target other players and so you have to account for them. If the game didn’t have real life death stakes, it would even just be something that people do for fun since that is a legitimate way to play the game.

Otherwise Kirito looks good throughout the adventure. He really tries his best to always protect Asuna and also respecting her boundaries. She tends to blow up at him quite a lot because the two of them get into a lot of dicey situations but that’s not even his fault. I would say that she’s slightly improving in that regard but not by a lot. She is still not being reasonable at all. Her worst moment aside from picking on Kirito is when she stops him from finishing off the assassin.

You need to keep in mind that this assassin has been following them across floors and revels in murdering folks. Letting him stay alive will mean the death of other players. Sure, Asuna may not end up meeting those other players but they will still die all the same. I thought it was extremely selfish to let him live. Kirito listens to her because at the end of the day he will always defer to Asuna but that was not a good decision. It’s not like the series even has much of a jail. We know from the main series that there will eventually be a big confrontation to wipe them all out but it’s hard to say how far in the future that is.

You need to enjoy that PK fight from the first adventure as well because once that’s over, there are really no more big fight scenes. The fight was really good too so it leaves you wanting more. The artwork has been consistently solid for most of the SAO titles and this one is no exception. There is a lot of attention to detail and the choreography is on point. The backgrounds and characters are all drawn well too.

Unfortunately this also means that the series can’t resist the urge to throw in a bunch of fanservice in the second volume. A good chunk of the conversations take place in the hot springs and character keeps forgetting where they are and stand up to talk. Those scenes could have definitely been cut out. It’s a shame because Kizmel is a solid ally who always shows up to help the main characters but she is inevitably used for fanservice. I can’t think of a time where she showed up to help without that quickly becoming the case. It’s like a destiny that she simply can’t get away from.

Regardless, she is a good character though and deserves better. Based on how her plot ends, I assume she will be returning in a future arc. She is going off alone to fight powerful NPCs but in theory the game’s story wouldn’t have her just die off screen right? It’s hard to say because NPCs can absolutely die out of nowhere but it would feel like a rather cruel plot. As for Kirito and Asuna, they’ll have plenty more adventures to go. I believe the characters beat the game on the 70th floor and they’re still around 6 so there are plenty of other floors to complete. At this rate I feel like this series will never end unless the author significantly picks up the pace.

It also feels like the series is using the Dark Elf questline as the overarching plot of the series. This may not be a good idea as it never seemed all that interesting to me. Even here there is a lot of lore about it and their enemy in the war but you’re just not all that invested. Perhaps you can say that about any NPC quest but this one just doesn’t have much of a hook. You care about Kizmel but that’s about it. It’s interesting to see her gaining skills whenever Kirito shows her a new move so you can do a fun plot like that. Maybe she survives longer than she should because of it and it changes the pre set route of the quest.

I’d personally rather have the PK gang be the main plot but I suppose they constantly show up so they may as well be. Those confrontations always have way more tension and the stakes are just higher. Admittedly it is annoying that they always catch Kirito when he’s paralyzed or can’t move but surely that has to end by the next round. Their poison pick also seems pretty OP in this game. The way Kirito acts, it would drain all of your health very quickly which is not something you ever really see in these RPGs. Kayaba may need to rebalance that.

Overall, This is a very quiet SAO title. It makes for a quick read and is easy to blast through but does fall into some easy pitfalls like the fanservice. I also would have appreciated more action but the banter between Kirito and Asuna is always good. He can’t resist messing with her like with the ghosts and she’s always beating him up for being in an inconvenient place at the wrong time. For some the relationship may be a bit too toxic but it’s always in good fun. It does make Asuna look bad to an extent but if Kirito doesn’t mind then you don’t mind as much either. This might be it for Progressive for a while but I’ll definitely be back as soon as another one comes out.

Overall 5/10

Sword Art Online Progressive: Barcarolle of Froth Review


Sword Art Online is one of the most frustrating franchises of all time. This is because the highs and lows are so drastic. You’ll go from watching one of the greatest movies of all time to watching a terrible season of the anime. You’ll play an amazing video game and then read a below average manga. Unfortunately this one is in that side of the camp. I wanted to enjoy it but unfortunately it was clear that this story wasn’t exactly focused on the plot.

This story takes place during the early days of climbing to the top of Aincrad. Kirito and Asuna are still stuck inside the death game that is known as Sword Art Online. The only way to escape is to clear the 100 floors and right now they aren’t even halfway to floor 10. Yeah it’s going to be a long journey and so they try to have fun while they can. They go on adventures ranging from making a boat to visiting an elf friend of theirs. Will they be able to keep their sanity in such a strange situation?

Now if I’m being extremely generous, you could say that a lot of the crazy shenanigans here is because that is how they are coping with this situation. Acting extra silly helps them take their minds off of the danger. That said, even I’m not quite this generous. It’s clear that the series is having fun using fanservice as a tool to move things around all the time. The fanservice within this series is constant and it really does drag the series down quite a bit.

I haven’t seen a series be this obnoxious about it since Fairy Tail. There is a certain amount that you can maybe overlook here and there but when it is this frequent and intense, well there is no escape at that point. There isn’t a single chapter without a little of that and it seems to be the main default for the title when it comes to humor. It’s a shame because there are so many ways to throw in good jokes without relying on fanservice.

Additionally, the series should have an advantage here in that the Kirito and Asuna romance is one of the few really good ones among any anime/manga. So this is really about building chemistry and that’s what the title should have focused on. Not constant excuses for getting to the beach and swimming. At least Kirito tends to stay strong and doesn’t panic as much as Asuna but he’s also portrayed as lightly taking advantage of the situation at times which is not what you’d expect from the hero.

As a result the plot takes a back seat here. It’s not like the story is all that complicated anyway though. It’s really about taking on side quests. The longest one is when the heroes make it back to the elf kingdom and have to help them stop some invaders. It’s not the biggest challenge that Kirito has ever faced but he wants a perfect victory without any NPCs hurt in the process. So he convinces the ruler to help out and then they claim a nice victory. The climax is fairly quick here. There was also a quick action piece for the side mission to build a bridge.

The artwork is pretty solid so the action scenes look really good. Unfortunately the fact that the art is really good also means that the fanservice is worse. It’s a true double edged sword when you really think about it. The pages are easy to read and so you’ll blast through this one quickly. It’s only two volumes long after all so this is very close to actually being a oneshot adventure. This is probably why I had even forgotten that Sword Art Online got so many different manga titles for a while there.

While Kirito is the one who tends to steal the show the whole time, Asuna does well on her own as well. I was glad the manga didn’t overdo it with showing her to be a newbie because by this point she should be experienced enough not to be making the day 1 blunders. Kirito naturally still has more experience all around which makes sense but it’s not like she’s lagging behind. Her combat skills are also really on point here. Her character tends to suffer for most of the fanservice moments but outside of those she is a quality character all around.

There isn’t time for much of the supporting cast to appear otherwise. You still have the two factions fighting each other to clear the floors quickest but Kirito always runs in to steal the last hit bonus anyway. Shows you just how much of a pro Kirito is. Argo is fun enough as she keeps trolling everyone by withholding information. I like that Kirito is able to hold his own with her by this point since he knows how she operates. They have a fun dynamic going on here. I’d even say it’s a great friendship dynamic.

Part of why the supporting characters can’t do much is also because the series just doesn’t have a very strong cast of them by this point. The franchise wouldn’t get better at that for quite a while but it’s fine because Kirito and Asuna are all you really need to lead the adventure. They have a good dynamic as well and I would be able to just appreciate the fun vibes of it. Honestly if you take out the fanservice then you have a very good story here. Of course a what if scenario doesn’t help the actual product. It’s a key example of how just one area can really sink a story.

Overall, I would say to skip this one. The Progressive series is meant to be an ultra extended look at the first arc which means that you can really identify more with the characters. At the same time, that means you can easily skip chunks of it like this one without really missing anything. Technically this could be treated like filler so it’s worth checking out if the story is good. Since it’s not, you’ll want to keep going on your way. The drastic changes in quality for the franchise really continues here. That’s just how it goes sometimes though.

Overall 3/10

FLCL Progressive Review


It’s time to look at the recent FLCL show. It’s been a while since I’ve seen such a terrible anime but leave it to this franchise to fix that. The first FLCL show is still considered by me to be one of the worst anime of all time. I’d have to say that it actually is in last place from the show’s that I’ve seen. This sequel is marginally better at best. It improves in the animation but certainly didn’t do anything to actually help the aimless writing and non existent plot.

The show starts off with a small segment of the main character in an apocalyptic future where Zombies run amok. They start destroying everyone and naturally a dog is included as well. This kind of show just can’t resist such things. Get used to these scenes of nonsense since they will be in almost every episode. Hidomi then wakes up and goes through life as normal. She wears headphones so she can pretend not to hear anyone even though no music is playing. It works though as people don’t really mess with her. That’s when she gets a new transfer teacher who decides to change her life. It turns out that Hidomi is another time bomb whose emotions allow her to summon giant monsters and even gain super powers herself. Her greatest ability is the Kirby suction power which allows her to absorb anyone who gets in her way. It’s basically a one hit ko tactic against just about everyone. There is another person who wishes to stop the heroine though so everyone has to keep their guard up.

This show is bad on so many levels so let’s start with some of the mild positives. Unlike the first show this one actually does have a few scenes where the animation looks pretty decent. It’s not that random experimental stuff we had to deal with in the older one. The animation is still pretty bad most of the time though. No effort is put into the character designs and nothing about this show tells you that this was made in 2018. It just doesn’t look nearly as good as it should and that’s because the show is trying (and failing) to be artistic. Enjoy the battle between Julia and Haruko as well as Hidomi vs Haruko since those fights are really the only times that the show gets to look good.

The soundtrack also isn’t good. It’s mainly just satisfied to grab some tunes from the old show and call it a day. Don’t expect to get any solid battle tunes or anything like that. This just isn’t that kind of show I’m afraid which is rather unfortunate. It’s how it goes I suppose.

Another tick against the show is the animal violence as I referenced earlier. Why did we need a dog to die in the zombie scenes? It really had no significance there and just served to help the show dig its own grave as always. The zombie scenes were also randomly violent despite the rest of the show not going that route. It’s all just for shock value.

The show can also be rather fanservicey which is just what I’d expect. It’s not extreme like Fairy Tail or anything like that, but it all adds up. Throw in the fact that the main cast is terrible and we’ve got some problems. The main guy’s two friends are both terrible. One guy is so bad that he has to hire a girlfriend which is as bad as it sounds. The other guy never actually gets anything to do and is only around to mock everyone. The main guy (Ko) tries to help Hidomi at least but he does have ulterior motives so I don’t count that in the slightest. He also loses every fight he is in which really does not help.

Then we have the main heroine Hidomi who is really hard to sympathize with. Her father left so she is waiting along with mother for him to come back. The issue is that he probably isn’t so the mother is hoping they can move on. Especially since she does all of the work while the main character shuts off life. She does help monetarily with her job at the cafe but certainly isn’t good for moral support. At least she finally initiated an attack on the teacher for the final episode but it took her way too long to finally try and be proactive. I would have liked to have seen her do something sooner and even in the final episode she ends up being extremely annoying and is unable to see the big picture so I can’t give her any props there either.

There is also the teacher from the first series who has become a straight up villain in this one. Haruko wants to sacrifice the main heroine so that she can meet up with a mysterious guy from her past. Maybe in a classier show with decent writing her dilemma could have actually been a little sympathetic. Maybe we could have seen her trying to find a different way to do this or something like that. Instead Haruko comes across as very unreasonable and likes to go about her plans in a very roundabout way. Most of her actions don’t even make sense so you just wonder how important her goal ever was to her.

Julia is Haruko’s rival and is always trying to get in her way. Julia will talk tough to Haruko about how this isn’t right, but spends far too long trying to convince her arch nemesis of this. After a while she should know that Haruko isn’t going to change and yet she doesn’t do anything about this. You can’t feel bad for Julia when she is inevitably beat up because that character never even had a good plan. I feel like none of the characters in this show are even remotely intelligent.

Then we have a bunch of random side characters like the plant owners. Their plot is just pointless and tries to add some mystery to the whole thing, but it fails quite badly. You’ll just be wondering why the show thinks you will end up caring about them when that is certainly not the case. If anything it’s the opposite and you’ll just be counting the minutes until the episode ends.

Overall, This show just couldn’t do anything right. The humor falls flat and the characters aren’t interesting in the slightest. The writing is horrendous. The battle scenes can be good but considering who is fighting it hardly matters. The show is just soulless and doesn’t do a good job of trying to prove that we can have a quality show in such a short amount of time. Anime should at least be 12 episodes if you ask me although in this specific situation I doubt it would have helped at all. I’d advise staying away from this anime. Keep your distance and you’ll be fine.

Overall 1/10