Suggested by Destroyer Nightmare is skilled with a sword and won’t back down easy. Lets ignore for a moment that Pyrrha Nikos couldn’t just manipulate his armor and crush the guy. His swordsmanship will be enough to help him clash with Pyrrha for a while, but even then she has the edge thanks to her speed. She would be landing quite a few blows on Nightmare while still being able to block or parry his. It’s a fairly one sided battle where the victor is never in doubt. Pyrrha Nikos wins.
Suggested by Destroyer Nightmare is a skilled warrior with a blade and his overwhelming physical strength allows him to move quickly even while holding such a heavy weapon. Alas, it simply won’t be enough to take Lazerman down for the count. Lazerman can easily dodge his blows and being able to fly also makes this fight even easier. Lazerman can blast away at Nightmare for awhile and while Nightmare can shoot fireballs if I’m not mistaken, the difference in skill is simply too large to ignore. Lazerman wins.
Once again it’s time for overwhelming power to fight super speed! Phantom (Zero) can run rings around Nightmare, but in terms of attack power is far weaker than Nightmare. Of course speed really helps in these fights. Nightmare may have the power, but what good is it if he can’t hit Phantom (Zero)? Phantom (Zero) wins.
Well I’m afraid Link has to knock down Nightmare a peg or two. Nightmare just didn’t have it in him to defeat Link. Link has a sword and skills that he can use to defeat Nightmare once and for all. Nightmare just didn’t have what it takes to win this time. Link wins.
This is a tribute to Enchanted. Nightmare has The Legendary Soul Edge, which is stronger than The Master Sword by a thousand times. While Giselle has an ordinary sword she has no chance. Nightmare wins.