Suggested by Destroyer Nancy Drew is a great detective, but I don’t think she is quite ready to win this fight. Katniss is used to fighting in very desperate situations and is able to adapt on the fly. A single hit from her arrows will take Nancy down for the count. Even if Drew knows what Katniss will do next, she won’t be able to evade the hit. Katniss wins.
Suggested by JHG195 It’s time for a battle of heroines. Neither one of these fighters actually likes combat, but they can hold their own when necessary. Nausicaä has good melee capabilities and a good gun at the ready. That gives her the long range edge as Katniss has her bow and arrow which isn’t quite as effective. Katniss is a great shot, but ultimately that still won’t be fast enough to help her and in a hand to hand battle my money would be on Nausicaä. Nausicaä wins.
This is a tribute to the Mockingjay Part 2 and the Avengers Confidential film. It works out perfectly since Katniss loses hers while Punisher is able to take his win. Simply put, Katniss looked terrible in the final Hunger Games film as she continues to under perform and showed me why I was never a fan of the character to begin with. On the opposite side of the spectrum was the Punisher, a villain who is actually relatable and has goals that I can sympathize with. One is an excellently crafted character while the other is poorly written and overrated. Guns also beat arrows while we’re on the subject. Punisher wins.
This is a tribute to Mockingjay Part 1. Katniss is a pretty good archer and her skills definitely can’t be denied, but she still won’t be able to stop Vegeta. She lost her fighting spirit at some point during her journey and she has yet to regain it. That’s just one of the reasons why she is no match here. Vegeta wins.
This is a tribute to the Hunger Games. Katniss knows how too use a bow and arrow, but she’s never dealed with someone as powerful as Bass. Bass is the ultimate being in all of media! He cannot be defeated by anyone, nor will he ever be defeated by anyone. Bass is just far too powerful. Bass wins.